I have worshiped in several different churches and chapels during my Christian life. Admittedly I enjoy Psalms and Old Hymns most during worship. And I do recognize the good new music that is more contemporary. I think there is even a good argument for it to be a necessary part of worship.
I think the problem is that very few worship leaders are conscious of the Bible’s view of worship. Answering questions such as “What is the purpose of worship?”, “What biblical guidelines do we have for worship?”, “What is the focus of worship?” and “What is the most important part of worship?” are important when making decisions concerning the organization of the music.
I think one particularly obvious habit of worship leaders is to be a performer instead of fellow worshiper. Two things that lend themselves to this are: 1) improvisation; and, 2) removing the musical text from the congregation’s hands.
I would not be doing my job if I failed to provide at least biblical implications that conflict with these tendencies. Paul speaks of being orderly in worship in 1 Corinthians 14. He concludes with verse 33, “For God is not a God of confusion but of peace”.
So when you, as worship leaders, invite the congregation to sing, it is necessary that they be given anything needed for them to join in singing so it will be organized or peaceful rather than confusing. If you have music, wouldn’t that help the people keep track of where you are and sing along? Couldn’t they follow along better if each note was not only provided but also kept to its proper length and timing? Instead of last minute changes (or at least last minute from our perspective) of where to jump in the music, why not provide a different order to begin with or explain it beforehand? Why jump to a completely different song in the middle of the one we’re singing? I am not terribly good with music. And I know these things will not make my singing better. But I would really like to worship God with you, could you help me by adding a little more order so I can sing along?